Missing Hollywood Executive: Was He Murdered in a Love Triangle? After hearing these stunning accounts from Gavin's wife and sons, they sensed his disappearance was no disappearance at all. 2023 Telepictures Productions Inc. "I think it was self-preservation. The defendant, Grace said, beat Smith to death with his bare fists. Paul J. Campbell: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know, John Creech: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know, Copyright 2023 Heavy, Inc. All rights reserved. "They don't know whether he is dead or alive," said Robert Grace. Like a rabid dog, Creech was protecting his turf. Femme fatale: Smith allegedly had an affair with Creech's wife, Chandrika (pictured), whom he met in drug rehab in 2009 Hikers discovered the remains about 70 miles away, near Palmdale in rural. John Lenzie Creech is brought into the L.A. Superior courtroom of Judge Stephen A. Marcus for sentencing for voluntary manslaughter in the 2012 death of 20th Century Fox executive Gavin Smith. John Lenzie Creech, 45, was convicted in July of involuntary manslaughter after a two-week jury trial in Los Angeles Superior Court. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. But according to that couple, staying together was a matter of financial convenience. And detectives cant compromise the investigation by going public. Lisa boldly drove two of her sons to John Creech's house to try to make peace. Chandrika Creech, after meeting her in drug . "This time Chandrika is going to drive to a predetermined location where they are going to meet," said Robert Grace. "He tells her that if she doesn't drive him back to the location, he's going to tell the police that she was involved in Gavin Smith's murder," said L.A. County Deputy District Attorney Robert Grace. They just felt that at that point if they came forward they were gonna be charged with something, so they wanted to keep their mouth shut," said Det. But Gavin Smith's own personal plotline took an R-rated turn, and his life became a tangled true-life mystery turned haunting thriller. My dad had never, never let us down like that, says Evan, now a personal trainer. But Creech's defense attorney told the Hollywood Reporter in 2012 that. In October 2014, Smiths remains were found in Palmdale, California. O'Brien. O'Brien. "The individuals that were involved in helping Creech to hide, none of them had prior criminal records," said Grace. Add a bio, trivia, and more. Maybe he started using drugs again. He took care of things," said Ed Addeo. Cade, who was granted immunity by prosecutors in exchange for her testimony, said she didn't go to the police because she was "terrified" of her then-husband. Speaking to the media, a Sheriffs Department lieutenant stated the investigators now know how and why Smith was murdered. A Los Angeles Superior Court jury found John Lenzie Creech guilty in July 2017 of voluntary manslaughter for the May 2012 beating death of Gavin Smith, a 57-year-old married father of three who was missing for 2 1/2 years before his remains were found in a shallow grave in the Angeles National Forest in the Antelope Valley. Temptation Island airs Tuesdays at 10 p.m. "That was evidenced to me by the fact that he had tried to chase down the car a few weeks earlier when he saw his wife get into a car with somebody so he was well aware that his wife was seeing somebody else. Now he's got a murder rap. He was very depressed.". Creech said he frantically checked Smiths neck for a pulse, and it dawned on him that he was likely dead, but he feared calling 911 because he had a criminal record. Creech testified in his own defense, telling jurors that he took "full accountability" for failing to call 911 after what he described as mutual combat or to seek help for Smith. She said she pulled the minivan alongside the Mercedes and yelled, "Stop, you're going to kill him." "He just really took care of himself.". John's wife, Chandrika Cade-Creech, had met Gavin at a drug rehabilitation facility in 2008. On May 1, the 57-year-old disappeared along with his black 2000 Mercedes E420 after leaving the house of a friend in Oak Park, where he was 'couch surfing.' He was reported missing the following. The larger-than-life Gavin Smith left a positive indelible mark on the lives of so many. Was John Creech capable of such violence? Palisades News, The Best Source of News, Culture, Lifestyle for Culver City, Mar Vista, Del Rey, Palms and West Los Angeles, Health Nut LA to Open Fourth and Fifth Locations in Santa Monica and Culver City, Nonprofit Initiates Winter Program to Foster Intergenerational Relationships, Marina Del Reys Ritz Carlton to Host National Charity League Westside Chapters Class of 2023 Senior Recognition Dinner-Dance, Culver City Arts Foundation Awards El Marino Rainbow Taiko $3,000 Grant. "He had called me on my birthday and he had mentioned a couple of things, 'It's not good.' Creech who faces a 25-year-to-life term if convicted of first-degree murder is serving an eight-year jail term for his no contest plea in September 2012 to one count of sale or transportation. The storage facility was rented to a friend of Creech. Working tirelessly for a shot at the NBA. In his closing argument, the prosecutor told jurors that Smith "was executed in cold blood by this defendant, who hit him repeatedly in the face" after using a cell phone with GPS to track down his estranged wife, Chandrika Cade, and sneak up on the two in Smith's Mercedes-Benz. Dolson said today that Creech "is still a person of interest." . "The way she describes it it was going to be like a family-to-family situation, and that if she was able to get quote-unquote 'the families together,' then Gavin would back off and Chandrika would back off and there would be no need for John Creech to be angry," said Grace. "Moving out at that time was not financially feasible," Cade said. They met near some commercial buildings where Chandrika "knew it would be quiet at that time of night." Gavin had driven his black Mercedes to the location. Posts. >> yeah. Victim suffers serious injuries in February 21 incident Culver City police continue to investigate an attempted murder that took place Sale finalized on January 30 By Dolores Quintana There has been some controversy surrounding the sale of Bruces Beach back Driver sought in connection to February 26 collision The Los Angeles Police Departments West Traffic Detectives are requesting the publics 51-unit now open at 11010 Santa Monica Boulevard In a ceremony held recently, the Weingart Center and local officials celebrated 144 apartments and retail planned for parcels at 3984-3988 South Meier Street and 12740-12750 West Zanja Street. The family said he had a cellphone charger, shaving kit, and other. Chandrika is sitting in Gavin Smith's lap," said Grace. Eon praline - Der TOP-Favorit unserer Produkttester. "John Creech states, 'You saved your father's life by coming here today,'" Grace said in court. "His whole thought process was regaining the relationship with his boys," said brother-in-law Ed Addeo. His family and authorities have been unable to locate him either through cellphone records or credit card billings. Despite the separation and the fact Creech was allegedly seeing other women, including an 18-year-old, he had a "double standard" for her. Detectives. Detectives would get the most critical pieces of evidence. linktr.ee/yesamalika. When Creech ignored her, she yelled, "You're gonna go back to jail. Dylan Smith, son of 20th Century Fox executive Gavin Smith, delivers an impassioned plea during victim impact statements at the sentencing for John Lenzie Creech, who was convicted of voluntary manslaughter. "At most, Lisa's statements to the deputies demonstrated that Gavin could be verbally abusive toward Lisa. "He had to do something and he did it. "We knew it was a homicide and then we had to find the body just to get some kind of closure," said Gavin's brother Greg Smith. Then he heads back to Stan McQuay's garage, where the Mercedes and the body have been sitting for five days. "They all have this AT&T family map plan with their cellphone plan, which allows you to be able to track ostensibly where your kids are," said Grace. He clenched his jaw and glared at the man in handcuffs a convicted drug dealer who beat his father to death and buried him in a shallow grave. The probation officer who wrote a pre-sentencing report for the judge said that Creech poses a potential threat to the victims family and society, and suggested he serve prison time. Despite his movie-star good looks, Gavin ultimately found his place behind the scenes at Fox, starting from the bottom up. ", "They could have known what happened to him on May 2nd instead of being in the dark for two years," the judge said, noting that it was "abundantly clear that the only thing that he (Creech) cared about was himself.". When his sons skimboarded, surfed or played basketball, he joined in. Wife Lisa had everything to gain, and nothing to lose. But Chandrika insisted she had no idea where Gavin was. O'Brien. They were all the center of Gavin's universe. Both Chandrika and John Creech had blood on their clothes. Grace told jurors that Creech and his wife had an "unconventional marriage" in which the two "both cheated on each other," and that it was "essentially a countdown to murder" when Creech "first uttered the threat" to two of Smith's sons in 2010 that he would kill Smith if he continued to see Cade. Evan Smith, son of 20th Century Fox executive Gavin Smith, gives a victim impact statement as defendant John Lenzie Creech is sentenced. LA City Council Exploring How to Boost Permanent Housing for the Homeless, Culver City Police Arrest Suspect in Attempted Murder Case, Heirs of Bruces Beach Finalize $20M Sale to LA County, LA Police Seek Publics Help in Identifying Driver Involved in Fatal Hit-and-Run on Venice Boulevard, Weingart Center and Local Officials Debut New Permanent Supportive Housing Complex in West LA, Developer Clears Hurdle for Housing and Retail Project on Border Between Los Angeles and Culver City, Homeless Encampments and Sleeping in Tents Banned in Culver City, MoviePass Executive Accused of Embezzling $260,000 for Coachella Party, American Youth Symphony Returns to Walt Disney Concert Hall This Weekend, Despite Recovery in Sales, Los Angeles Restaurants Report Lower Profit Margins Than National Average, Experience the Future of Chipotle at Farmesa, the Chains Latest Concept Store in Santa Monica. Powered by. Cops make their move, but they don't have to go far to find John Creech. The familyhas offered a $20,000 reward for any information about the missing executive. In January of 2015, the Los Angeles County District Attorneys Office charged body builder John Creech with Gavins murder. He needs to be in walls, she said, like the animal that he is.. In his opening statement Thursday, Deputy District Attorney Bobby Grace told jurors that the threat Creech made to Smith's two sons was "a downpayment to murder.". "We were guarded on releasing information because if we give out too much information, we don't know if somebody's telling us what they heard on the news or what they witnessed or what they know as a fact," said Det. John Creech was even floored by the gutsy move. Cade and Smith met when she was attending a treatment center for alcohol abuse. Frankly, youre a cold and cruel person Marcus told Creech. Creech, a 44-year-old convicted drug dealer, could face life in prison without the possibility of parole if he is convicted of first-degree murder and if jurors find true the special circumstance allegation of murder while lying in wait. Chandrika Creech is the wife of John Creech, an admitted drug dealer who is currently in jail on a drug charge and has been named as a "person of interest" in Smith's disappearance. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a188e5e1e5c2a71 All Rights Reserved. John O'Brien. "They can't get life insurance proceeds because there's been no legal determination that he's dead.". Ad Choices. Robert Grace. When Smiths wife, Lisa, stood behind a lectern, her hands shook and she took deep breaths to quiet her sobs. My dad and I got along swimmingly, recalls Evan, who along with his girlfriend Kaci Campbell, is featured on the reality dating show Temptation Island, airing Tuesdays at 10 p.m. He was also a National Championship winning college basketball star with UCLA in 1975. Gavin's mistress Chandrika Creech gave up nothing to detectives at first, but spilled her guts to an informant, revealing that her jealous bodybuilding drug-dealing husband John Creech gave the popular studio exec a world-class beating, left him battered inside his black Mercedes, and threatened to do the same to her. "We knew that we had to look at John Creech and his wife Chandrika Creech, and we had to basically clear them from any type of allegations," said Det. KTLA reports that in September 2012, four months after Smith went missing, Creech pleaded no contest to the sale or transportation or sale of drugs. A Sage and Seekers in-person group at Notre Dame High School. Ken Lee at People Magazine, Smith was having a relationship with Chandrika Creech, who he met in rehab three years earlier. Police also confirmed that the married Smith, 57, had met Creech's wife, Chandrika, 39, in rehab in 2009. "Yes, they were all culpable in what they did, in the cover-up, the hiding of evidence, but ultimately there was only one man who caused the death of Gavin Smith, and he was our main focus," said Det. It was revealed, during the course of the investigation, that Smith had spent time in rehab where he met a woman named Chandrika Creech. John Creech, 39, told Chandrika he was done with her -- in fact, he had fallen in love with an 18-year-old girl still in high school. Maybe he's in a hotel somewhere,'" said L.A. County Sheriff's Detective John O'Brien. Sept. 15, 2017 Best of NBC News Play All Nightly. "He did not want me to see Gavin ever," she testified. Man who killed Fox executive having an affair with his wife gets 11 years in prison A Los Angeles jury convicted John Creech, 44, of voluntary manslaughter in the beating death of Gavin Smith, a. Hollywood Executive's Wife and Investigators Break Their Silence on His Disappearance and Brutal Death. The alleged events took place May 1, 2012, the night prosecutors say Smith was killed. "And at that point, especially when he bit down on my thumb, I really tripped out.". The team of willing cohorts grows even larger. "I was crying and pleading with him not to do anything to my father.". Not guilty of first-degree murder; not even second-degree murder; but guilty of voluntary manslaughter. Chandrika knew that defendant was trying to call her after she left the house, but she did not answer her phone. "Your actions after beating Gavin Smith are egregious, heartless, callous. John Creech arrived a few minutes later on foot. detective john o'brien and ty labay had a problem. Asked how many times Creech punched Smith, Cade replied, "Honestly, too many times to count. "There was no doubt in her mind that Gavin was dead," said L.A. County Sheriff's Det. I'm too young to lose my dad,'" Austin Smith testified. And there was another dark damaging shadow cast over the Smith family in the form of an exotic young beauty named Chandrika Creech. Creech's attorney countered that the May 1, 2012, confrontation between the two men got physical and her client had to "defend himself" and do a "leg sweep" when Smith came at him wielding something that looked like a hammer and ice pick. "I just don't know how they could come to that conclusion. Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day. Rich L.A. homeowners are snapping them up, Column: Supreme Court conservatives may want to block student loan forgiveness. "The Smith family was able to declare Gavin Smith deceased.". So, I knew something was wrong, I knew something was up.. Chandrika Creech Age 40s | Yucaipa, CA View Full Report Phone | Current Address | Public Records | Criminal Records Top Result for Chandrika Creech 1 The best result we found for your search is Chandrika Creech age 40s in Yucaipa, CA in the Central Yucaipa neighborhood. So detectives paid a visit to the mistress. Creech, 39, was arrested by Glendale police in 2010 for making a drug drop and pleaded guilty, according to local reports. He becomes a caddie at a high society golf club and found his new career path -- but not as a golfer. Smith's wife and two of the couple's three sons urged the judge then to impose the maximum sentence on Creech. Extended testimony from Chandrika Creech as she reflects on her actions the night Gavin Smith was killed in California's San Fernando Valley. And then I went back to USC and studied for an exam I had the next day, Evan recalls. "I think they should get prison sentences, and here they're walking, they're skating and it's just wrong," said Greg Smith. "John Creech is straddling him, according to Chandrika, and being repeatedly punched by Creech -- Gavin Smith, to the face," said Grace. Whitmore said detectives had spoken to Chandrika Creech and had served 25 to 30 search warrants in the sensational case. Even assuming Gavin had been verbally abusive toward Lisa, that would not support defendant's theory that Gavin had a violent character and therefore was the aggressor in the confrontation.". Smith had met Creech's wife, Chandrika Creech, in rehab in 2009, according to the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department. The victim's widow told the judge that Creech beat her husband to death and never wanted his family to find him. After catching the two one evening, Creech allegedly beat Gavin. Then, in October 2014, hikers discovered his remains in a desert grave near Palmdale, Calif. For more on how Temptation Islands Evan Smith is coping with the murder of his movie executive father, subscribe now to PEOPLE or pick up this weeks issue, on newsstands Friday. I don't even understand that logic, because there's no right to kill somebody.". "They're separated but living together, according to those parties," said Robert Grace. Creech is now serving an eight-year sentence. And all you cared about was yourself," said L.A. County Superior Court Judge Stephen Marcus. Her husband, John Creech, "remains a person of interest," Dolson said today, adding that the storage locker where Gavin's car was found was linked to Creech via a person "very closely associated . Chandrika was married to convicted drug dealer John Creech. Creech faced up to 11 years for the crime. Grace told the jury that Creech had decided to murder the 57-year-old Smith after Creech's wife, Chandrika Cade, had reignited a love affair that began in 2008 when Smith and Cade met at the Matrix rehabilitation center in Woodland Hills, California. Benz 420 E. Smiths Mercedes was recovered on Feb. 21, 2013, at a storage facility in Simi Valley. "That's how they became friends, and then later, lovers.". Evan recalled when, after Creech learned about the affair in 2010, he and his younger brother went to Creechs house to beg him not to hurt their dad. He was one of my best friends. "The injuries to his face is equivalent to falling off a two-story building and landing face-first," said Det. Sheriffs investigators searched a home in the San Fernando Valley on Friday in connection with the case of missing 20th Century Fox movie executive Gavin Smith, who disappeared more than a month ago. You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times. 3:05 p.m.: This article was updated with additional details from the sentencing hearing, as well as Creechs criminal history. I basically just told him that I was very apologetic for his behavior, and that I promise you that my dad would never talk to your wife ever again, and Im so sorry that hes hurt you and your family, Evan says. . Robert Grace. O'Brien. 176.31.79.7 In June of 2012, police found Smith's black Mercedes Benz 420E at a Simi Valley storage facility that belonged to John Creech, which appeared to be a significant lead. The jury had much to consider once it went into deliberation, but it took less than an hour for nine women and three men to come back with a verdict. O'Brien. Nunez also asked why Cade didn't seek medical attention when Creech allegedly body slammed her into objects and hit her in the face, to which Cade replied, "It didn't leave any marks. At the time of his disappearance, Gavin had moved out of the family home and was temporarily living with a friend. As it turns out, Chandrika was not honest when she first told cops she hadn't seen Gavin and didn't know what happened to him. Reels. Video related to john creech: 5 fast facts you need to know, Search for Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith Continues, Search for Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith Continues Dina Kupfer reports. He said detectives had searched Creech's home and car, but declined to. Prosecutors claimed that Smith began an affair with Creech's wife, Chandrika Cade, after meeting in a drug rehab facility. Lisa tells detectives her husband is cheating with Chandrika Creech. A jury in July rejected prosecution arguments that Creech, 45, committed murder when he killed Gavin Smith after catching him in a romantic tryst with Creechs wife, but the panel convicted him instead of voluntary manslaughter. Chandika Cade, Chandrika Winata Creech, Chandrika W Creech, Chandrika Winata. John Creech, 42, pleaded not guilty to the charge included in the indictment and is due back in court April 27, according to the District Attorney's Office. At trial, Deputy Public Defender Irene Nuez told jurors that her client acted in self-defense after Smith choked him, gouged at his eyes and threatened him with a tool resembling a hammer and an ice pick. On sentencing day, Gavin's wife and oldest son unleashed seething wrath on John Creech. Then the jury hears that Gavin Smith was wielding a deadly weapon that night. "There was cracks in his skull all leading from the front facial area to the back," said L.A. County Sheriff's Det. The final scene: a tragic fade to black. He says 'Yeah, but in six months I'll know everything you know, and I'll do it better,' and he did," said Ed Addeo. Evan never saw his father alive again. "The break in the case comes when the police get a tip as to a storage facility that has a Mercedes-Benz," said Grace. "The two of them would go and talk to John Creech and basically in an effort to get John Creech not to hurt their father," said Grace. A Fox film executive who is believed to have met with foul play was officially ruled dead today on the two-year anniversary of his disappearance, a Sheriffs official confirmed. He wore a pair of purple athletic pants belonging to one of his sons and left his cellphone charger, shaving kit and other items. quotes a source as saying Smith and . He's beaten to a pulp by a jealous husband on steroids. Canoga Park. VIDEO: Gavin Smith was last seen in Oak Park 2 1/2 years ago. Give this man the maximum today for savagely ripping my dad out of my life, Smith told a judge in a downtown Los Angeles courtroom. "He couldn't live without them, and they weren't helping, and so he's taking too many.". More than a dozen. Authorities refused to provide details about the search, but said no arrests had been made. She later drove him back to within about a block of the beating scene. An Intrepid Police Investigator Solved the Mystery: 'Never Give Up', Bono on Discovering He Has a Half-Brother from His Late Father's Affair: 'I Love and Adore' Him, In 'Captive Audience', the Stayner Family Opens Up About Navigating an Impossible Reality in the Spotlight, Convicted Drug Dealer Convicted of Manslaughter But Acquitted of Murder in Death of Fox Movie Executive, How a Conch Shell Held the Key to a Woman's Cold Case Murder and Revealed a Family Betrayal, Former Oklahoma Police Officer Gets 25-Year Sentence for Killing Daughter's Boyfriend, Convicted Drug Dealer Indicted in Murder of Fox Executive Gavin Smith, Will Smith Recalls Last FaceTime with Dad Before His Death: 'We Got the Opportunity to Get Finished', Alex Murdaugh's Brother Is 'Shocked' to Learn of Younger Sibling's Alleged Financial Crimes, Drug Addiction. Toward the end of the hearing, Marcus, the judge, explained that one thing he considers in deciding a sentence is whether the defendant displayed a high degree of viciousness. "It was a little bit out there to believe that this was a murder right at the get-go," said Det. Creech, 42, was officially charged on January 29. "Here, the evidence was not probative, and the exclusion of it was not erroneous,'' the panel determined. Click here to get breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases in the True Crime Newsletter. An accused killer's ex-wife testified Monday that she saw her then-husband beat a 20th Century Fox distribution executive unconscious when he discovered her kissing the victim in the front seat of the man's Mercedes-Benz. "(Creech) told Gavin to stay away from me and shoved him against the wall," Cade said. For two and a half years those same people kept the crime a secret while detectives poured out blood, sweat and tears trying to solve it, and the family suffered with the unknown. The Hollywood Reporter is a part of Penske Media Corporation. John Lenzie Creech and his attorney, Deputy Public Defender Irene Nuez, look toward the Smith family during the sentencing. UNLOCK PROFILE. Supervisors Janice Hahn and Holly Mitchell commemorate the signing of State legislation to return the land to the closest living heirs of the Charles and Willa Bruce. "Eleven years isn't enough, but I understand that's the maximum you can give him.". Anyone with information on the case was urged to call the Sheriffs Homicide Bureau, (323) 890-5500. After Smith disappeared on May 1, 2012, authorities searched for clues at the spots hed last been seen, and the Fox executives family offered a $20,000 reward. But still, no body. But Gavin Smith's personal life took an R-rated turn, and his life bec. Creech then sneaked up on them and committed an act of almost stunning brutality, the prosecutor told jurors. NBC reporter Andrew Blankstein tweeted that Creech is in prison serving eight years on drug charges. But he said Creech told them there would be "problems" if their father contacted Cade again. Sind Sie auf der Suche nach dem ultimativen Eon praline? Detectives last year asked for the publics help in identifying whoever was involved in moving Smiths car from the Porter Ranch area to the storage facility on or about May 8 or 9, 2012. The investigation into Smiths death is ongoing, she said. "She only knows her husband was responsible for getting rid of Gavin Smith's car and the body, but she doesn't know exactly where they are," said Deputy D.A. Prosecutors handed a seemingly solid case to jurors, parading to the stand each and every person who had a hand in helping cover up the crime. "The boys basically said 'Listen, we know that our father is having an affair with your wife and that we're very sorry about it. Evan Smith, 28, remembers a childhood filled with basketball, surfing and movie screenings with his dad, Gavin, a Hollywood studio executive and former UCLA Bruins basketball player. She. A SWAT team and county homicide investigators descended on a cul-de-sac home in the 8600 block of Santa Susana Place in West Hills in the early morning hours June 8, using a loudspeaker to tell residents to come out, according to neighbors who spoke to the LA Times. "My partner and I would look at each other and we'd change our minds, 'Oh, maybe he's a missing person. "He surprised him and he began to physically attack Gavin Smith, who's seated in the front passenger seat," said Robert Grace. His decomposed remains were discovered in a remote area in Antelope Valley, California, by hikers in October 2014. I believe he went out there to find her in the company of Gavin Smith,'' the judge said, noting that Creech used a telephone app to track down his wife. The Pride LA In November 2014, the Los Angeles Times reported that Creech has been named as a person of interest. Times crime writer Richard Winton tweeted that Smith knew Creechs wife. I don't think it took a big leap to see that person was Gavin Smith, so I believe that he did go out there for the purpose of confronting and dealing with Gavin Smith in this circumstance," the judge added. Smith, 57, an 18-year veteran of Foxs distribution department and former UCLA basketball player,was last seenon the night of May 1 at a friends residence in Oak Park, an affluent Ventura County community. Creech was "always very protective and possessive," Cade said. Robert Grace. "We found some DNA from John Creech on the key fob and also on the front license-plate screw," said Det. DUIs. Creech checks Gavin's pulse. Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Stephen Marcus imposed the maximum sentence for the manslaughter conviction, the Los Angeles District Attorney's Office said in a statement. Marisa Gerber is a narrative writer at the Los Angeles Times. John O'Brien. The defendant testified that Smith threw the first punch, choked him and tried to gouge out his eye as the two men struggled inside Smith's car -- with the prosecutor later telling jurors that the injuries to Smith and Creech were "not consistent with self-defense" and that Creech's subsequent actions demonstrated a "stunning consciousness of guilt.